{
 "version": "gate-v1",
 "thresholds": {
  "colour_delta": 10.0,
  "quiet_ratio": 0.5,
  "not_quieter_ratio": 1.0,
  "garment_band": [
   0.05,
   0.2,
   0.95,
   1.0
  ],
  "pixel_change": 40,
  "stable_pct": 3.0
 },
 "threshold_origin": "The print bound was chosen on these development renders: plain tops scored 0.11 to 0.42 of the bought blouse's edge detail and patterned tops 0.50 to 0.70. The stability box and pixel threshold are the held-out study's frozen values. This report is therefore not an unseen test of the gate.",
 "code_sha256": {
  "exchange/fidelity_gate.py": "b1347d1961c00a7d1d490a250ed8f49ef8ef093844b9a1d114012252ae1ab614",
  "exchange/colour_check.py": "62f0dc45fcc3484197f30e042a3c0a7613e3bf671a314895bc7e5133cd027828",
  "exchange/gate_evaluation.py": "b5326cba7cc224d85811c164097003451770067c2c7b8f870d6c4e87d7d834ae",
  "exchange/gate_labels.py": "f0781580cb79aaaa8860f8da30f6968fd2efa9a2f2889a49dc4a91dbbabe7de6"
 },
 "summary": {
  "live_study": {
   "alternatives": 6,
   "shows": 3,
   "print_quieter": 6,
   "print_measured": 6,
   "colour_close": 3,
   "stable": 8,
   "renders": 8
  },
  "live_study_v2": {
   "people": [
    "model-f",
    "model-g",
    "model-h",
    "model-i"
   ],
   "renders": 32,
   "busy_not_shows": {
    "n": 4,
    "of": 8
   },
   "busy_print_above_quiet_ratio": {
    "n": 2,
    "of": 8
   },
   "plain_print_quieter": {
    "n": 16,
    "of": 20
   },
   "plain_shows": {
    "n": 12,
    "of": 20
   },
   "plain_colour_close": {
    "n": 16,
    "of": 20
   },
   "renders_stable": {
    "n": 25,
    "of": 32
   },
   "verdicts": {
    "shows": 16,
    "check": 0,
    "concern": 12
   },
   "repeats": [
    {
     "model": "model-b",
     "sku": "CALM-04",
     "first": {
      "status": "differs",
      "delta": 13.6
     },
     "repeats": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-33",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 13.6
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-36",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 13.6
      }
     ],
     "flag_recurs_in_every_repeat": true
    },
    {
     "model": "model-b",
     "sku": "CALM-03",
     "first": {
      "status": "differs",
      "delta": 19.4
     },
     "repeats": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-34",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 19.6
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-37",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 19.4
      }
     ],
     "flag_recurs_in_every_repeat": true
    },
    {
     "model": "model-c",
     "sku": "CALM-07",
     "first": {
      "status": "differs",
      "delta": 11.1
     },
     "repeats": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-35",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 10.9
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-38",
       "status": "differs",
       "delta": 11.1
      }
     ],
     "flag_recurs_in_every_repeat": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "renders": 62,
  "references": 9,
  "alternatives": 53,
  "verdicts": {
   "shows": 25,
   "check": 6,
   "concern": 22
  },
  "print_measured": 46,
  "print_agrees_with_catalog": 36,
  "print_not_measured": 7,
  "colour_concerns": 14,
  "stability_measured": 63,
  "stability_changed": 7,
  "known_failure_flagged": true
 },
 "labels": [
  {
   "rater": "AI reviewer",
   "model": "claude-sonnet-5-5",
   "kind": "ai",
   "independent": false,
   "file": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/labels-ai.json",
   "sha256": "049802dee00421bbb92c77e6b9f1db4a006c89d5539f28328a9d2f9358f86996",
   "items": 38,
   "agreement": {
    "print": {
     "agree": 28,
     "answered": 34,
     "unclear": 0,
     "disagreements": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-31",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-19",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-23",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-11",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-03",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-27",
       "gate": "not quieter",
       "rater": "quieter"
      }
     ]
    },
    "colour": {
     "agree": 16,
     "answered": 26,
     "unclear": 0,
     "disagreements": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-19",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-20",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-37",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-34",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-33",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-38",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-03",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-27",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-36",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-35",
       "gate": "differs",
       "rater": "matches"
      }
     ]
    },
    "outside": {
     "agree": 30,
     "answered": 38,
     "unclear": 0,
     "disagreements": [
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-31",
       "gate": "unchanged",
       "rater": "changed"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-19",
       "gate": "unchanged",
       "rater": "changed"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-08",
       "gate": "changed",
       "rater": "unchanged"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-07",
       "gate": "changed",
       "rater": "unchanged"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-01",
       "gate": "changed",
       "rater": "unchanged"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-25",
       "gate": "unchanged",
       "rater": "changed"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-04",
       "gate": "changed",
       "rater": "unchanged"
      },
      {
       "id": "gate-study-v2-17",
       "gate": "unchanged",
       "rater": "changed"
      }
     ]
    }
   }
  }
 ],
 "human_raters": 0,
 "human_consensus": null,
 "cases": [
  {
   "id": "pilot-01",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-a",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-01-model-a-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "9d4e588c6a2fdf9dd6f179835dd1d70cdefe50de68b7221032456c2fabee7564",
   "result_sha256": "c963a7e55c51c3cf81f7560b032fa8f6c33329dbb7ab343c617334e875fb9371",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 1.8
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 28.69,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.42
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-02",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-a",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-02-model-a-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "9d4e588c6a2fdf9dd6f179835dd1d70cdefe50de68b7221032456c2fabee7564",
   "result_sha256": "4dc261116ca865ee683caf92c5d7b4636b610dc760a5b65923725ee69cb7ceb3",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 69.11
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-03",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-a",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-03-model-a-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "9d4e588c6a2fdf9dd6f179835dd1d70cdefe50de68b7221032456c2fabee7564",
   "result_sha256": "9e7e6c4132b981a696742ed2b1cf5621d85288b0cae105f7e008597b062f2a00",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 5.5
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 14.42,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.21
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-04",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-01",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-04-model-b-CALM-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "6958eccc43f28308d3f4c601f04fd500f446c11e5a57c3f80389265d4db29a59",
   "result_sha256": "a38fc214f4c487f2d214babc0d3e59cb0de9d6dcf82a586da0f595d316f92fa5",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 6.4
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 23.29,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-05",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "BOLD-01",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-05-model-b-BOLD-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "6958eccc43f28308d3f4c601f04fd500f446c11e5a57c3f80389265d4db29a59",
   "result_sha256": "bcfc1526694ea35c1431fb867ea36c4f5a0c92ff2138bee6e1a0789cb5f2c486",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 48.67,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-06",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "OVER-01",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-06-model-b-OVER-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "6958eccc43f28308d3f4c601f04fd500f446c11e5a57c3f80389265d4db29a59",
   "result_sha256": "0951d961a0b4304c891657df3f1274ac309ef31eeeb3f5af97852ddc12ac9196",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Burgundy Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 2.7
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 9.81,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-07",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "BOLD-02",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-07-model-c-BOLD-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "4f9eb72815d6b5733380b914a12ab5aa4afb89bb175472dd155326d3fe8439ac",
   "result_sha256": "b73eb1567384536899c851703381a5250e8b016a13f57a92a77c667c8c34fcec",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 34.91,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-08",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-08-model-c-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "4f9eb72815d6b5733380b914a12ab5aa4afb89bb175472dd155326d3fe8439ac",
   "result_sha256": "61362a1ec80a5e0c9f245fdd260a4595c9cf16f176a0eb810df3c87f07d11fae",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 2.7
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 30.49,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-09",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-02",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-09-model-c-CALM-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "4f9eb72815d6b5733380b914a12ab5aa4afb89bb175472dd155326d3fe8439ac",
   "result_sha256": "c0fe02b20645adaa55867cd7f9fb4f08946f2565c2500e44d033ba58e6e260e9",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 1.5
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 52.71,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "check",
   "note": "Check this preview yourself: print could not be measured.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "pilot-10",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "SHORT-03",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-10-model-c-SHORT-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "4f9eb72815d6b5733380b914a12ab5aa4afb89bb175472dd155326d3fe8439ac",
   "result_sha256": "a49213e23cf6e30a9def610bc0419b6710542635aae0930029e13269b03a6778",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sky Blue Tee",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 14.8
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 23.04,
   "print": {
    "status": "not_measured",
    "ratio": null
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-01",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-d",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-d-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/01-model-d-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5532ae3a4a9bc610fde4595609d752f3e61a38baa71e59907532efe27ab4693f",
   "result_sha256": "260a0d4d43574eaaa615d1fa6b3cb1fb0bc473c3387d9f86285a18d2622478ba",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 68.58
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-02",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-d",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-d-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/02-model-d-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5532ae3a4a9bc610fde4595609d752f3e61a38baa71e59907532efe27ab4693f",
   "result_sha256": "2c9ebc52936703eca85dd3624a470e43f15601faad9f784690c0d398816783c6",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 0.9
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 26.24,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.38
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-03",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-d",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-d-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/03-model-d-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5532ae3a4a9bc610fde4595609d752f3e61a38baa71e59907532efe27ab4693f",
   "result_sha256": "d2d9cde26f82cf43ad4b930e3e042506d2e094f7120acc3b18fbfa2c06e07825",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 3.7
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 7.86,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.11
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-04",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-e",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-e-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/04-model-e-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "67d2767282236551243037aa6ae83a1b752e98ae4a1173124035514f4821a09e",
   "result_sha256": "01b69c6d71884fb9cd9af991bbb8737e0472120233c3d8439ce82d7ede235ce7",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 74.88
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-05",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-e",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-e-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/05-model-e-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "67d2767282236551243037aa6ae83a1b752e98ae4a1173124035514f4821a09e",
   "result_sha256": "9d7894d482a50ab2c68028f8ebf28c9d16471f2f057dd453f4bcea1bd50062af",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 5.5
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 27.23,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.36
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "heldout-v1-06",
   "split": "held_out",
   "model": "model-e",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/model-e-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/heldout-v1/06-model-e-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "67d2767282236551243037aa6ae83a1b752e98ae4a1173124035514f4821a09e",
   "result_sha256": "9e80ffd4b79557eceb4d029d3851bd9cdabef400e957e81e954bd7e1e094c4b5",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 2.5
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 9.22,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.12
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-01",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/01-model-b-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "b8e84fe8055a79c9d31a8c0a1bb83ad33fff0369e4a4670db6d7e4f993bbd8c9",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 70.01
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-02",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/02-model-b-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "2df2abf529474d1e4907274e6eb41c45674d6933a5a8147074553992ab3ff5ef",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 13.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 28.11,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.4
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-03",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/03-model-b-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "eba9b306239a4e60eac17dabeb0e61b24ae57c08c71a9ac256380f69b35b77af",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 6.2
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 9.82,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.14
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-04",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/04-model-b-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "ea9b810e4f924aaab152d7e9967e8084caa98f699803d4fa1bc02124c8c67539",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 19.4
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 24.94,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.36
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-05",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/05-model-c-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "d9b8a9f91d8aa61d233479ec5f6b5f6ae2e0ef0a5d5db59a0bf93777fef73106",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 72.17
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-06",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/06-model-c-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "8bbde50dd17d7151ea4b39cb9dd7da2ab0cd85e8635646d56bfe157db15a74ef",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.8
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 30.96,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.43
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-07",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/07-model-c-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "34daa763576784190cb8edc47fdc7662a045d6d6bb78ae701bec73b6271d807a",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 11.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 17.16,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.24
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v1-08",
   "split": "live_study",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v1/08-model-c-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "dab22bdf4b18540c8b8e47db9913dabec9ffa481356480526bc2bed0e5671641",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 2.7
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 30.43,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.42
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-01",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "study_role": "reference",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/01-model-f-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "5b68260981e9b329a0597ca3a4f23e57d6dd8033b716a60846c59cb5ebd97a1d",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.1
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 79.78
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-02",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "CALM-01",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/02-model-f-CALM-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "2357828acde7ee1f5e0ce81b1d6fec1ee564b43dfbb7d8d038012581caa9dd49",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.62
   },
   "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 30.73,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.39
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-03",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "CALM-02",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/03-model-f-CALM-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "cf1fbd5fc1f19bdbb2d064a3c8803a2e9ad1727e8c22133f9b992a5f065f0564",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.29
   },
   "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 13.3
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 41.64,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.52
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo; the print is not quieter than the top you bought; more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-04",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/04-model-f-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "26c82d4de9693d3c9f366f7710a1e9e92de25a4e26cd8659863859594d1b3ad7",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.03
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.2
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 38.18,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.48
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-05",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/05-model-f-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "463c60582dd62212f795c5ff14c060c4c7ca0608fbce52c4009bc8bd87dbb1ef",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 2.96
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 1.8
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 33.87,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.42
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-06",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/06-model-f-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "1686f25694af121195844763090d597dc385007125a474d1aeedacb6622f6b59",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 4.5
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.0
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 10.36,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.13
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-07",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "BOLD-01",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/07-model-f-BOLD-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "86bfb7f0993fa0b3bdd82069c36168a20cefca03af0940d57605ade2e9266fe9",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.05
   },
   "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 35.36,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.44
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-08",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-f",
   "sku": "BOLD-02",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-f-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/08-model-f-BOLD-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ab910d348b4bae3c3a76307a1bf74b3247cea210ff26812f0442a752f1ae3d7d",
   "result_sha256": "755a92ffb9a64210ec086bea1a20621707bd88b742480f53c2e3924cea5cb0a9",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 3.41
   },
   "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 34.53,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.43
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: more than the garment changed.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-09",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "study_role": "reference",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/09-model-g-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "0d46f4d9b1ec62fbbeda28a6424c10e8e3816c3f21d85ea9a9ec2c3c7b707066",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 70.11
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-10",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "CALM-01",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/10-model-g-CALM-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "89c23e3d4a7c598fa5733d11f7d0bf6621b8024cfc62854acac3b4d6de22d5c0",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 32.54,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.46
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-11",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "CALM-02",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/11-model-g-CALM-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "b5e448ee5e6fbc509a29020c85b0a52fb95ba298f47b1b23b5c3acf6c52a2bf0",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 4.9
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 37.38,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.53
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the print is not quieter than the top you bought.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-12",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/12-model-g-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "5bee9c27804882c3e73ab006ab5e7fe3e7a0d6f227581a5ed9f88bf7a320c7ea",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 7.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 24.02,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.34
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-13",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/13-model-g-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "a093cb7b65b3362bad377611330af38dbe1a5d2b3e84a3c2033a6375c1f3f9cb",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 6.0
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 23.87,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.34
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-14",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/14-model-g-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "629bebc43e28ae537531f0255a34f75a9485665c0df0c0ba8767098d67a387e4",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 8.3
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 19.32,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.28
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-15",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "BOLD-01",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/15-model-g-BOLD-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "571c3d78eb7aa902e857acdea4f15f7a589c3cb2e5a3d000d57dd786056888ed",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 31.94,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.46
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-16",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-g",
   "sku": "BOLD-02",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-g-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/16-model-g-BOLD-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "ba8dadf90d751d9700da86d3566dd590d31c485146f13506f7334aff2036eb99",
   "result_sha256": "37cd03944171254cc3b7b873c5b71b02c046df0689153159e9b01097e6cc15d4",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 33.51,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.48
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-17",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "study_role": "reference",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/17-model-h-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "bf18c69e6b5807d2f3fb9de4fa309097ee507ff212bc892fb241b859d9ec153a",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 61.58
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-18",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "CALM-01",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/18-model-h-CALM-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "9eacabfec9a7dcbc11952a600bb39bd883cce23511b71b67ce4c087461812331",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 8.0
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 18.26,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.3
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-19",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "CALM-02",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/19-model-h-CALM-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "1ed2273ca32d8f5cb56172c830313c4b4e134f2b67e2b737315a858fcc0ddf74",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.05
   },
   "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 19.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 31.68,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.51
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo; the print is not quieter than the top you bought.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-20",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/20-model-h-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "0b633e0026614c89349c0a66b35ebc7b25633fd5961cc8b28cbbbf85cda28078",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 10.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 20.98,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.34
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-21",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/21-model-h-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "b1811bde75c1f5ad372b513482ac4ac82deacada7b7fb69c06d76ce92be55ee6",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 7.9
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 23.78,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.39
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-22",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/22-model-h-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "73e2a02c67a5390b42b315368936927f7d3e50091ca485831644887bac90a677",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 7.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 6.58,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.11
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-23",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "BOLD-01",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/23-model-h-BOLD-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "26b608dd2e379b0c4c741a10043d84f2792bdb777a6b9b665d04bb9403806f75",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 35.64,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.58
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the print is not quieter than the top you bought.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-24",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-h",
   "sku": "BOLD-02",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-h-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/24-model-h-BOLD-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "5509709c9c50b6927a126c4c35bdbcb2e59ece7d170312c9dd6ae46f9482c05e",
   "result_sha256": "25eb0706a196167cfb4e33dbed84e3d025ce4b40f811490337e2b7fe305677c0",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 27.91,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.45
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-25",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "ORIGINAL",
   "study_role": "reference",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/25-model-i-ORIGINAL.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "1778b84055af547b049718a158b09c0540043f622c355fa8b62db7daa7abed62",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "reference",
   "busyness": 69.38
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-26",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "CALM-01",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/26-model-i-CALM-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "2dd4c8c49336a8896724141a04023c1dff95dd6cb5d909ab4f297d7dff839bf9",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 5.8
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 27.63,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.4
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-27",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "CALM-02",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/27-model-i-CALM-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "29036d5826a7ed47bbd858ba344d927cff8b8cb45d2690fbef55c349a2af6077",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 46.3
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 48.04,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.69
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo; the print is not quieter than the top you bought.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-28",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/28-model-i-CALM-03.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "8c0f8551dcdef5284881e60ffc0a682d0ab7b99a50b7cba018815c1f63503ade",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 8.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 25.08,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.36
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-29",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/29-model-i-CALM-04.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "96a75718208a46cfa47a41ec60bef4353dc7b9449ac4ee9d7bd88e348b962a5b",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 0.5
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 29.34,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.42
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-30",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "plain",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/30-model-i-CALM-07.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "b912d85ae26d1cd7fcd93f8a1dba1ecf99e4f1473109535a842517f54a8a35d7",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "close",
    "delta": 5.2
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 9.75,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.14
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-31",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "BOLD-01",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/31-model-i-BOLD-01.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "9e314d6966daa6d2528e2e4a2c3bf79cd4c98019415341f7bd6dc01098101cfa",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 38.51,
   "print": {
    "status": "similar",
    "ratio": 0.56
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the print is not quieter than the top you bought.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-32",
   "split": "live_study_v2",
   "model": "model-i",
   "sku": "BOLD-02",
   "study_role": "busy",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-i-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/32-model-i-BOLD-02.jpg",
   "person_sha256": "f779ed14cc9d25b86a3b7a88acd55a7717b2e82aa4db1ca9f560ee9795378bfd",
   "result_sha256": "35c1dea01d8754059ac872e159894631922d4ef4b9b08fff36f0a5a9876a2a4a",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
   "pattern_level": 2,
   "colour": {
    "status": "pattern",
    "delta": null
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 34.55,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.5
   },
   "verdict": "shows",
   "note": "Measured checks agree with your request: colour, print and stability.",
   "catalog_quieter": false
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-33",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/33-model-b-CALM-04.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-02",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "53672f55cb382283db5a7dd90f57357e51080ad5469aba27ffdb6467767b2228",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 13.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 28.12,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.4
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-34",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/34-model-b-CALM-03.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-04",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "a24624f2fc309613178e11483af557c404504e54cfe8990a45af37640a8f9864",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 19.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 24.96,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.36
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-35",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/35-model-c-CALM-07.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-07",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "bbf26146ce8a4b5430565d90d93591bc95a3878e99c64aee11c9c0b6c5fe8ac3",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 10.9
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 17.41,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.24
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-36",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-04",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/36-model-b-CALM-04.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-02",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "2df2abf529474d1e4907274e6eb41c45674d6933a5a8147074553992ab3ff5ef",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Sage Knit Top",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 13.6
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 28.11,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.4
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-37",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-b",
   "sku": "CALM-03",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-b-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/37-model-b-CALM-03.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-04",
   "person_sha256": "ead3ee8bfed07b1b5a8b0098273f289eafb7c76980d33c5cd02cf529f705edb9",
   "result_sha256": "ea9b810e4f924aaab152d7e9967e8084caa98f699803d4fa1bc02124c8c67539",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 19.4
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 24.94,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.36
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "gate-study-v2-38",
   "split": "repeat",
   "model": "model-c",
   "sku": "CALM-07",
   "study_role": "repeat",
   "person_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/model-c-input.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/gate-study-v2/38-model-c-CALM-07.jpg",
   "bought_split": "live_study",
   "repeat_of": "gate-study-v1-07",
   "person_sha256": "c0dc199ba2e28804ca2380e7ca31770f772a3aca4ddb5d2185b3daed53f3229b",
   "result_sha256": "b24388e4772f9a2d82ea33a2c1c1e327ec6063273c373e44dad73318c01a2863",
   "stability": {
    "status": "stable",
    "outside_change_pct": 0.0
   },
   "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
   "pattern_level": 0,
   "colour": {
    "status": "differs",
    "delta": 11.1
   },
   "role": "alternative",
   "busyness": 17.66,
   "print": {
    "status": "quieter",
    "ratio": 0.24
   },
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "This preview does not show what you asked for: the colour differs from the product photo.",
   "catalog_quieter": true
  },
  {
   "id": "bag-probe",
   "split": "development",
   "model": "model-a",
   "sku": "BAG-RED-HOBO",
   "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
   "result_image": "exchange/evidence/bag-probe-model-a-BAG-RED-HOBO.jpg",
   "known_failure": true,
   "person_sha256": "9d4e588c6a2fdf9dd6f179835dd1d70cdefe50de68b7221032456c2fabee7564",
   "result_sha256": "c306c511fd279924daa32969fcd3b7fbf10f658c2c53f69ca1f8f2584fe0851d",
   "stability": {
    "status": "changed",
    "outside_change_pct": 54.95
   },
   "title": "Red slouch shoulder bag (rejected probe)",
   "verdict": "concern",
   "note": "The gate flags the probe that redrew the whole scene."
  }
 ],
 "limits": [
  "Print busyness is mean edge strength inside the garment area; it is not a judgement of taste or a pattern classifier.",
  "The stability measurement uses a fixed garment band; hands, hair and shadows inside the band are not checked.",
  "Sleeves and neckline are not measured; they remain catalog facts.",
  "A verdict of shows means the three measurements agree with the request; it does not establish fit, fabric or exact colour.",
  "Colour is compared with the catalog colour without correcting for the light in the photo. In gate-study-v2 the blind AI rater accepted all ten renders the colour check flagged, allowing for the photo's lighting.",
  "Print busyness also counts construction detail. The utility shirt's pockets, buttons and seams read as not quieter on all four new photos, where the blind AI rater saw a plain shirt.",
  "The two patterned sweaters registered as tops that should fail were weak negatives: a yoke band and broad stripes are less busy than the dense floral, and the blind AI rater judged all eight quieter. A live test against a top as busy as the blouse is still to be run.",
  "On the full-length photo Clothes V4 also redrew trousers and waistlines in some renders; the stability band flagged seven of its eight renders, at 3.0 to 4.5 percent, including the blouse itself.",
  "The protocol named the owner as a second, human rater; the owner chose not to label, so only the AI rater is reported."
 ]
}
