{
  "protocol_version": "1.0",
  "protocol_frozen_on": "2026-10-29",
  "scope": "Retrospective development evidence from published pilot images, not a held-out accuracy benchmark.",
  "summary": {
    "outcomes": 36,
    "plain_colour_measured": 7,
    "plain_colour_close": 6,
    "patterned_not_scored": 3,
    "relative_size_compared": 2,
    "relative_size_close": 1,
    "size_warnings": 1,
    "size_corrections_passed": 1,
    "uncalibrated_shades": 12,
    "prior_ai_reviews": 10,
    "new_complete_reviews": 0,
    "requested_difference_reviewed": 0,
    "metrics_split": "development",
    "development": 36,
    "held_out": 0
  },
  "split_metrics": {
    "development": {
      "outcomes": 36,
      "plain_colour_measured": 7,
      "plain_colour_close": 6,
      "patterned_not_scored": 3,
      "relative_size_compared": 2,
      "relative_size_close": 1,
      "size_warnings": 1,
      "size_corrections_passed": 1,
      "uncalibrated_shades": 12,
      "prior_ai_reviews": 10,
      "new_complete_reviews": 0,
      "requested_difference_reviewed": 0
    },
    "held_out": {
      "outcomes": 0,
      "plain_colour_measured": 0,
      "plain_colour_close": 0,
      "patterned_not_scored": 0,
      "relative_size_compared": 0,
      "relative_size_close": 0,
      "size_warnings": 0,
      "size_corrections_passed": 0,
      "uncalibrated_shades": 0,
      "prior_ai_reviews": 0,
      "new_complete_reviews": 0,
      "requested_difference_reviewed": 0
    }
  },
  "thresholds": {
    "garment_delta": 10.0,
    "relative_size_tolerance": 0.15,
    "pixel_change": 40
  },
  "target_regions": {
    "tops": [
      [
        0.05,
        0.2,
        0.95,
        1.0
      ]
    ],
    "lip": [
      [
        0.25,
        0.35,
        0.75,
        0.8
      ]
    ],
    "foundation": [
      [
        0.1,
        0.1,
        0.9,
        0.9
      ]
    ],
    "nail": [
      [
        0.0,
        0.0,
        1.0,
        0.85
      ]
    ],
    "earrings": [
      [
        0.0,
        0.2,
        0.4,
        0.85
      ],
      [
        0.6,
        0.2,
        1.0,
        0.85
      ]
    ],
    "necklace": [
      [
        0.1,
        0.25,
        0.9,
        0.9
      ]
    ],
    "hair": [
      [
        0.05,
        0.0,
        0.95,
        0.7
      ]
    ],
    "shoes": [
      [
        0.0,
        0.55,
        1.0,
        1.0
      ]
    ],
    "bag": [
      [
        0.1,
        0.2,
        0.9,
        0.95
      ]
    ],
    "look": [
      [
        0.05,
        0.1,
        0.95,
        1.0
      ]
    ]
  },
  "rubric": {
    "product_detail": [
      "recognizable",
      "partly_changed",
      "misleading",
      "not_assessed"
    ],
    "requested_difference": [
      "visible",
      "not_visible",
      "not_applicable",
      "not_assessed"
    ],
    "unrelated_parts": [
      "preserved",
      "changed",
      "not_assessed"
    ],
    "misleading_result": [
      "yes",
      "no",
      "not_assessed"
    ]
  },
  "reviewer": null,
  "dependencies": {
    "pillow": "12.3.0"
  },
  "input_sha256": {
    "assets/preview_evaluation_protocol.json": "e432e95770a46e8c138cb9a4437ea4dd85fe3ced214323c9c029b14ed6ad1af2",
    "assets/reference_colours.json": "2d2d8ac083bbf9df5fd1c82c8662b552ec4914f514dc08f6c10cb7b9e2a77631",
    "exchange/colour_check.py": "62f0dc45fcc3484197f30e042a3c0a7613e3bf671a314895bc7e5133cd027828",
    "exchange/preview_evaluation.py": "5fa145453c711c2af942ecb6d0585bd10b35e49f539ffdd82cfd555358da546c",
    "exchange/size_check.py": "6bc4f819bca77ada21edf2b3f16bd38dc5dba13579953ee5ae970972e53187e4",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/BAG-RED-HOBO.jpg": "36d17084d1301a4aa78fa87e8f029c384923c1a1e8f223622abe779ab1615e29",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/SHOE-CREAM-PEEP.jpg": "b5cacd5bcdc7dfa59f0f1a7a9770d9072a901df03d7e67d18b368dfaa4774ade",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/SHOE-GOLD-BROGUE.jpg": "471ab58d38e03ccf131d6617f0804844888dce385406d01fa57b4cb002cdeb52",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/SHOE-NUDE-PUMP.jpg": "eb450ea33883c94ac576dee7743edc90d32dc35a1827384bd334dea1483d6781",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/SHOE-RED-BOOT.jpg": "9b30682b101c33e841571a8f49789c4f2b56489750c0c962d8c5ecb7ef1a3d68",
    "exchange/static/exchange/accessories/manifest.json": "b73abfd70776b55a5b4306e5525881c9f658f9d95a4fd06b5f14c63a90e018ce",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/BOLD-01.jpg": "b3a0131286ff09191386aead403d819dcf94cf3a9332c4420d2e46488cdf154f",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/BOLD-02.jpg": "378dd611f6b500720f2b18f1e20cf85c03b516b4fcfa77c9fcc4e6c635f2d6c4",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/CALM-01.jpg": "9c01f38d0ad9ec0e95dd242e08732710187be97bcb075dcf3e02bb8db50c7984",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/CALM-02.jpg": "af06664a1e6ea375907af69e28354eb00e42709c8761877eb21b25e6a3511b0a",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/CALM-03.jpg": "e642bfb43b4d8fbb5c1c6ee340086d13593c7146d2326569b2c9c3899d1ad63b",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/CALM-04.jpg": "68c157ecd80ec7e044381fbd4fedbcd6bcb275005255fbbb68394aabb435c09b",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/CALM-07.jpg": "5f9278d5a91c434034eb4282ba5498e6f0d19998d39374f18d507b964031fa49",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/ORIGINAL.jpg": "7669c094ef0d1be3627a13ca06b6b4d2e40268d33869be2a6f84aa7e0b1b0377",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/OVER-01.jpg": "6a33f1ddebf7b9d71d3fc9841a3d105e6e65fd73436cd0fc39b5b748d3102502",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/SHORT-03.jpg": "10e08c18d96f87d01c03fb631615fcfc2bc9ba92c6f2cf596d028e21c080f00b",
    "exchange/static/exchange/catalog/manifest.json": "02a65d4975bdf5edc2120a77425d3fb60fda92498dc5e1bc7d154038e8ccba5f",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/accessories.json": "d0b4f2b821cebcaa305379c98070a99f02f137dd5363565d625cf143f6a2f1b5",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/bag-probe-model-a-BAG-RED-HOBO.jpg": "c306c511fd279924daa32969fcd3b7fbf10f658c2c53f69ca1f8f2584fe0851d",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-01-face-a-LIP-VELVET-230.jpg": "548653b585983a3cf1c0fb0f74b2b74e7516c242178c85492ee261aad324ca53",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-02-face-a-LIP-VELVET-220.jpg": "10187a4eed4f18bdaa54c33b8749dc50dd4b646fd7ee94608d5baef640f85240",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-03-face-a-LIP-VELVET-240.jpg": "f16f4a3e500b41dfb515386a26dbb7b154c1ac138e81026806a58d9ab334b373",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-07-face-a-FDN-VEIL-220W.jpg": "a86d74aec58b1e593c065d58fce5270df1612d3a1fe7fe96f6fe62e0d55026c6",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-08-face-a-FDN-VEIL-210C.jpg": "4bdd4793da79ddb976d8d3f11c808234a4e39e3911abe7a89fece3bcea2de818",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-09-face-a-FDN-VEIL-310C.jpg": "1d8c075514d506be13a2b30957f8b00327d7485d911211ebcd0b9fdd6ba92381",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-11-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-01.jpg": "973a990082cd13a6f772bd80cdcf0b8a87e6ee65841a9d441bc6b3459081b08d",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-12-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-02.jpg": "119f434b8de7c810560b80a6217f860d616c477a221fc579563e88cc9d03a508",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty-13-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-04.jpg": "88c81f62ec25d0398cc9a9c55b5f040e4719e3c137bc7f7797742e611aeaf691",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/beauty.json": "3cefc5c1ef45f5f7c2909308b6f6ec6239e736e97e77ab4d4ec334e08cdae776",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/earrings-01-face-a-EAR-PEARL-G58.jpg": "76cb894781679e6ceb4573289a7226ff1681480c96197dbf38c6f2e42657d32b",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/earrings-02-face-a-EAR-CRYSTAL-S38.jpg": "0e5b867aa7530e7e4b99832337dd38bd63e537170d238ebe780f9be185f5a170",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/earrings-03-face-a-EAR-TOPAZ-S12.jpg": "27d12a319d43895b402c1ad96506d3a92cce9c92c930eaf33bc0930c989f24dd",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/hair-01-model-a-HAIR-TONE-7.3.jpg": "a6834705d0ebc49cf411d7d5a5e1a15b7b3ab5a7831fd1dada76e19cdbe840ab",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/hair-02-model-a-HAIR-TONE-7.1.jpg": "671c11decae7c427cc192d0f97e4d23fd15def9a2d9b750c3984f77414ea0b0d",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/hair-03-model-a-HAIR-TONE-6.1.jpg": "471154b7077a5b2f62abc2cb2bdae374b05cb0b50db5ef83b385a261281f87c3",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/hair.json": "2773a908cef13579f2ddeee07089839c6ce71e99ca9d9d02f8ae648d3c93072e",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/jewellery.json": "9bf8b862dbc7d796e9f88aadd60547af4fba33779de3d520ed9d4fefe9cd8fb0",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/look-01-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg": "8f1b09df1590f0aa617660934393e37034839fa7da5c2bccdf82f9dee1b5712a",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/look-02-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg": "f53bdc3ab42743e23c5d58ba2c32e9a9e5e66625f50b594f6720082431abaade",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/look-03-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg": "9b578951ac26de1b99be9c638f4a5a4e575c370becca0fe345e9ab6e2e340c2c",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/looks.json": "d22fbbeb302f32d9da9adf22fd3acaba7ccd7ce6f0e5b4270b62492f12754bb2",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/necklace-01-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg": "f3ddf5886eda79b58c239dde3f72ff62175c03ca42fa7711ede14ded179e4afd",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/necklace-03-model-a-NECK-BLOOD-S40.jpg": "b9570b91d55181a173278e3a8bbb0eb5b0e7615ef760f7e22a2ba94171846fb8",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/necklace-04-model-a-NECK-LAPIS-S45.jpg": "47bec556e02267afad8b006d4bfae27f6552c22b00dd46f14a6772e606a2c0ef",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/necklace.json": "854763acf42ca70b3ec1dec8ebd83527ab2dd912af5baa3115fe734e4913ae90",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-01-model-a-CALM-04.jpg": "c963a7e55c51c3cf81f7560b032fa8f6c33329dbb7ab343c617334e875fb9371",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-02-model-a-ORIGINAL.jpg": "4dc261116ca865ee683caf92c5d7b4636b610dc760a5b65923725ee69cb7ceb3",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-03-model-a-CALM-07.jpg": "9e7e6c4132b981a696742ed2b1cf5621d85288b0cae105f7e008597b062f2a00",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-04-model-b-CALM-01.jpg": "a38fc214f4c487f2d214babc0d3e59cb0de9d6dcf82a586da0f595d316f92fa5",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-05-model-b-BOLD-01.jpg": "bcfc1526694ea35c1431fb867ea36c4f5a0c92ff2138bee6e1a0789cb5f2c486",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-06-model-b-OVER-01.jpg": "0951d961a0b4304c891657df3f1274ac309ef31eeeb3f5af97852ddc12ac9196",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-07-model-c-BOLD-02.jpg": "b73eb1567384536899c851703381a5250e8b016a13f57a92a77c667c8c34fcec",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-08-model-c-CALM-03.jpg": "61362a1ec80a5e0c9f245fdd260a4595c9cf16f176a0eb810df3c87f07d11fae",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-09-model-c-CALM-02.jpg": "c0fe02b20645adaa55867cd7f9fb4f08946f2565c2500e44d033ba58e6e260e9",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot-10-model-c-SHORT-03.jpg": "a49213e23cf6e30a9def610bc0419b6710542635aae0930029e13269b03a6778",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/pilot.json": "830f50b9ceadd2e8ae7e4bfe24f2159458bab2e472e6fc02bc998ca6df2af7f3",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/shoes-01-model-f-SHOE-RED-BOOT.jpg": "2c94138c133c640d853bb4d072378fd2d21667244f2cd7a7110ef980ee4ee6e1",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/shoes-02-model-f-SHOE-CREAM-PEEP.jpg": "f460e8cb8c47f79dd13ae342fb01d776b641fc974fc8a52b0df26b14f5d1f4b6",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/shoes-03-model-f-SHOE-GOLD-BROGUE.jpg": "6191ee0908e64af8d6ae89c7102a69fdaf1d50453f30f6a1e5589f64f92fa892",
    "exchange/static/exchange/evidence/shoes-04-model-f-SHOE-NUDE-PUMP.jpg": "1605d94f07410b2344a18986fb287809079e23da36ab0d54795cad46de652b40",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/EAR-CRYSTAL-S38.jpg": "6b377a544292d7b242b0c7f51a52ca127be00ea53d8d486dd4b6067f7c4bd875",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/EAR-PEARL-G58.jpg": "c170aa834f12f14a209288f989ee3db0675c41116f6a6561005a4f1762492a06",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/EAR-TOPAZ-S12.jpg": "041477d5a0a6b2634726e786a05daacba81860e87694e461111d3f9af119cda1",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg": "1a6a0a5190bce4f7bf493abd77e15022b798e2af8051eb314054df9e76b6d471",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/NECK-BLOOD-S40.jpg": "55940d2ba607f25649e41072070d59bf19cee11c15e252da019aeb23259689c3",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/NECK-LAPIS-S45.jpg": "a04c43048c50e51418479efa4d3f81760991fa1176b7d350380517dd4b5b0e6c",
    "exchange/static/exchange/jewellery/manifest.json": "b0f0a7fb11abfffc0ead2e800bacfc5b8b0c5a1e7bfef956c01d339ebdba5e75",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/face-a.jpg": "0a56237730e4c504a7f7b51023d06341d8062c5ae1407e2394e3d14ab7d708f6",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/hand-a.jpg": "614f5f94adabb8b62790f99ef0eff36ec992fe44b847fb49cbec2cd32327af24",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/model-a.jpg": "9d4e588c6a2fdf9dd6f179835dd1d70cdefe50de68b7221032456c2fabee7564",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/model-b.jpg": "6958eccc43f28308d3f4c601f04fd500f446c11e5a57c3f80389265d4db29a59",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/model-c.jpg": "4f9eb72815d6b5733380b914a12ab5aa4afb89bb175472dd155326d3fe8439ac",
    "exchange/static/exchange/models/model-f.jpg": "1db99453a3ad1e48e78d615ac433e3b6f934f0d005921269a76f3645fc0c2065"
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "pilot-01",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "CALM-04",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-01-model-a-CALM-04.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Sage Knit Top",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/CALM-04.jpg",
      "purpose": "Plain knit; long sleeves drawn over bare arms",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Plain green knit, crew neck and long sleeves all kept; the heather texture survives.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 1.8,
          "reference_hex": "#607e77",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-02",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "ORIGINAL",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-02-model-a-ORIGINAL.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Midnight Floral Blouse",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/ORIGINAL.jpg",
      "purpose": "Busy floral print; does the pattern survive",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 1
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "The floral on navy is broadly kept with smaller flowers; the shirt collar is drawn as a softer open neck.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "pattern",
          "delta": null,
          "reference_hex": "#343a53",
          "note": "Patterned top: the preview may simplify the pattern. Check the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-03",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "CALM-07",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-03-model-a-CALM-07.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Ribbed Turtleneck",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/CALM-07.jpg",
      "purpose": "Turtleneck detail; source is on a dress form",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 1,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Ribbed red turtleneck kept; the cuffs gain a small ruffle that the source does not have.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 5.5,
          "reference_hex": "#69111d",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-04",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "CALM-01",
      "model": "model-b",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-04-model-b-CALM-01.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Indigo Denim Shirt",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/CALM-01.jpg",
      "purpose": "Collar, buttons and chest pockets",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 1,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Collar, buttons, both flap pockets and the yoke are kept; the sleeves are drawn rolled up.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 6.4,
          "reference_hex": "#25365e",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-05",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "BOLD-01",
      "model": "model-b",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-05-model-b-BOLD-01.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Fair Isle Knit Sweater",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/BOLD-01.jpg",
      "purpose": "Fair Isle yoke; source includes mannequin legs",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 1
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Fair Isle yoke and fuzzy body kept; a grey layer shows at the neck and cuffs, likely from the mannequin.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "pattern",
          "delta": null,
          "reference_hex": "#5a4438",
          "note": "Patterned top: the preview may simplify the pattern. Check the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-06",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "OVER-01",
      "model": "model-b",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-b.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-06-model-b-OVER-01.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Burgundy Knit Top",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/OVER-01.jpg",
      "purpose": "Plain dark knit on a dark-shirted model",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Plain burgundy knit kept closely despite the dark shirt underneath.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 2.7,
          "reference_hex": "#533a3e",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-07",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "BOLD-02",
      "model": "model-c",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-07-model-c-BOLD-02.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Sunset Stripe Sweater",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/BOLD-02.jpg",
      "purpose": "Bold horizontal stripes",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Navy body, red, yellow and teal bands, striped sleeves and ribbed cuffs all kept; the bottom band runs out of frame with the photo.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "pattern",
          "delta": null,
          "reference_hex": "#6c4d5e",
          "note": "Patterned top: the preview may simplify the pattern. Check the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-08",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "CALM-03",
      "model": "model-c",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-08-model-c-CALM-03.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Heather Mauve Knit",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/CALM-03.jpg",
      "purpose": "Plain light knit",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Plain mauve knit, crew neck and long sleeves kept.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 2.7,
          "reference_hex": "#866b6c",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-09",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "CALM-02",
      "model": "model-c",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-09-model-c-CALM-02.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Khaki Utility Shirt",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/CALM-02.jpg",
      "purpose": "Utility shirt with pockets; arm crosses the torso",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 1,
          "neckline": 1
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Collar, pockets and buttons kept; it is styled open at the neck with rolled sleeves, which the product may not suit.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "close",
          "delta": 1.5,
          "reference_hex": "#b39152",
          "note": "Colour check: close to the product photo."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot-10",
      "source": "pilot",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "tops",
      "sku": "SHORT-03",
      "model": "model-c",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-c.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/pilot-10-model-c-SHORT-03.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-19",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4",
      "title": "Sky Blue Tee",
      "product_image": "exchange/catalog/SHORT-03.jpg",
      "purpose": "Short-sleeve control case",
      "prior_review": {
        "garment_detail": {
          "pattern": 2,
          "sleeve": 2,
          "neckline": 2
        },
        "person_stability": "stable",
        "usefulness": "usable",
        "reason": "Short sleeves and crew neck kept; the blue comes out noticeably lighter, which the colour check flags.",
        "reviewer": "Claude (AI assistant) at the owner's request, 2026-10-27"
      },
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "garment_colour",
          "status": "differs",
          "delta": 14.8,
          "reference_hex": "#3381ac",
          "note": "Colour check: this preview looks lighter than the product. Trust the product photo for colour."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-01",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "lip",
      "sku": "LIP-VELVET-230",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-01-face-a-LIP-VELVET-230.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.1",
      "title": "230 Terracotta",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "Lip probe: confirms the Makeup VTO lip payload. The purchased shade in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 4.5,
          "reference_hex": "#b5532f",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-02",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "lip",
      "sku": "LIP-VELVET-220",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-02-face-a-LIP-VELVET-220.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.1",
      "title": "220 Rosewood",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's first cooler shade",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 2.7,
          "reference_hex": "#a04a55",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-03",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "lip",
      "sku": "LIP-VELVET-240",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-03-face-a-LIP-VELVET-240.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.1",
      "title": "240 Mauve",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's second cooler shade; with pairs 1 and 2, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 4.3,
          "reference_hex": "#9c5a6e",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-07",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "foundation",
      "sku": "FDN-VEIL-220W",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-07-face-a-FDN-VEIL-220W.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.0",
      "title": "220W Light Warm",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "Foundation probe: confirms the Makeup VTO foundation payload. The purchased shade in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 7.4,
          "reference_hex": "#d9ae7f",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-08",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "foundation",
      "sku": "FDN-VEIL-210C",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-08-face-a-FDN-VEIL-210C.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.1",
      "title": "210C Light Cool",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's first cooler shade",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 6.3,
          "reference_hex": "#dcb2a3",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-09",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "foundation",
      "sku": "FDN-VEIL-310C",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-09-face-a-FDN-VEIL-310C.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "makeup-vto-1.1",
      "title": "310C Tan Cool",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's second cooler shade; with pairs 7 and 8, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": null,
          "reference_hex": "#b8877a",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-11",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "nail",
      "sku": "NAIL-GLOSS-01",
      "model": "hand-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/hand-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-11-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-01.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "nail-vto-1.1",
      "title": "01 Coral Crush",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "Nail probe: confirms the Nail VTO payload and that the demo hand is accepted. The purchased shade",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 2.1,
          "reference_hex": "#ef6f5a",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-12",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "nail",
      "sku": "NAIL-GLOSS-02",
      "model": "hand-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/hand-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-12-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-02.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "nail-vto-1.1",
      "title": "02 Cherry",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's first cooler shade",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 6.9,
          "reference_hex": "#b3203a",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "beauty-13",
      "source": "beauty",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "nail",
      "sku": "NAIL-GLOSS-04",
      "model": "hand-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/hand-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/beauty-13-hand-a-NAIL-GLOSS-04.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-27",
      "provider_version": "nail-vto-1.1",
      "title": "04 Lilac",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's second cooler shade; with pairs 11 and 12, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 4.4,
          "reference_hex": "#b9a3d6",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "jewellery-01",
      "source": "jewellery",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "earrings",
      "sku": "EAR-PEARL-G58",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/earrings-01-face-a-EAR-PEARL-G58.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "earring-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Baroque Pearl Drops",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/EAR-PEARL-G58.jpg",
      "purpose": "Earring probe: confirms the Earrings VTO payload and that Face A's ear is found. The pair bought in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "size_reference_sku": "EAR-PEARL-G58",
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "relative_size",
          "status": "size-reference",
          "note": "Size check: the pair bought, which the other sizes are measured against.",
          "rendered_px": 142,
          "corrected_status": null
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "jewellery-02",
      "source": "jewellery",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "earrings",
      "sku": "EAR-CRYSTAL-S38",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/earrings-02-face-a-EAR-CRYSTAL-S38.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "earring-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Blue Crystal Drops",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/EAR-CRYSTAL-S38.jpg",
      "purpose": "The demo's first suggestion for smaller and silver: same style, shorter",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "size_reference_sku": "EAR-PEARL-G58",
      "corrected_image": "exchange/evidence/evaluation-jewellery-02-resized.jpg",
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "relative_size",
          "status": "size-differs",
          "note": "Size check: renders 50% longer than its length implies. Check the length in the product details.",
          "rendered_px": 140,
          "corrected_status": "size-close",
          "corrected_px": 92,
          "corrected_sha256": "e45e0f5e80b673efb24071864eb678bfd02de1079d4027840c932c8bc241b3ab"
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "jewellery-03",
      "source": "jewellery",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "earrings",
      "sku": "EAR-TOPAZ-S12",
      "model": "face-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/face-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/earrings-03-face-a-EAR-TOPAZ-S12.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "earring-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Blue Topaz Studs",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/EAR-TOPAZ-S12.jpg",
      "purpose": "The demo's second suggestion: a silver stud; with pairs 1 and 2, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "size_reference_sku": "EAR-PEARL-G58",
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "relative_size",
          "status": "size-close",
          "note": "Size check: renders in proportion to the pair bought.",
          "rendered_px": 28,
          "corrected_status": null
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "necklace-01",
      "source": "necklace",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "necklace",
      "sku": "NECK-AMETHYST-S55",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/necklace-01-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Amethyst Y Chain",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg",
      "purpose": "Necklace probe: confirms the Necklace VTO payload and that Model A's neck is found. The pair bought in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "necklace-03",
      "source": "necklace",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "necklace",
      "sku": "NECK-BLOOD-S40",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/necklace-03-model-a-NECK-BLOOD-S40.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Bloodstone Bib",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/NECK-BLOOD-S40.jpg",
      "purpose": "The demo's suggestion for shorter in silver; with pairs 1 and 2, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "necklace-04",
      "source": "necklace",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "necklace",
      "sku": "NECK-LAPIS-S45",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/necklace-04-model-a-NECK-LAPIS-S45.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Lapis Collar",
      "product_image": "exchange/jewellery/NECK-LAPIS-S45.jpg",
      "purpose": "A collar at a middling length, to see a second collar form",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "hair-01",
      "source": "hair",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "hair",
      "sku": "HAIR-TONE-7.3",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/hair-01-model-a-HAIR-TONE-7.3.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "hair-color-1.0",
      "title": "7.3 Golden Blonde",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "Hair colour probe: confirms the AI Hair Color payload on a half-body photo with the hair down. The shade bought in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 16.3,
          "reference_hex": "#c08f45",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "hair-02",
      "source": "hair",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "hair",
      "sku": "HAIR-TONE-7.1",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/hair-02-model-a-HAIR-TONE-7.1.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "hair-color-1.0",
      "title": "7.1 Ash Blonde",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's first cooler shade for \"too brassy\"",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 31.0,
          "reference_hex": "#9f8572",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "hair-03",
      "source": "hair",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "hair",
      "sku": "HAIR-TONE-6.1",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/hair-03-model-a-HAIR-TONE-6.1.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "hair-color-1.0",
      "title": "6.1 Dark Ash Blonde",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The demo's second cooler shade; with pairs 1 and 2, a complete recorded comparison",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "applied_shade",
          "status": "uncalibrated",
          "delta": 11.2,
          "reference_hex": "#7a6b62",
          "note": "Exploratory colour reading only; no calibrated match or requested-change verdict."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "accessories-01",
      "source": "accessories",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "shoes",
      "sku": "SHOE-RED-BOOT",
      "model": "model-f",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-f.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/shoes-01-model-f-SHOE-RED-BOOT.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "shoes-v3-1.0",
      "title": "Red Heeled Ankle Boots",
      "product_image": "exchange/accessories/SHOE-RED-BOOT.jpg",
      "purpose": "Shoes probe: confirms the Shoes V3 payload and that Model F's feet are found. The pair bought in the demo",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "accessories-02",
      "source": "accessories",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "shoes",
      "sku": "SHOE-CREAM-PEEP",
      "model": "model-f",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-f.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/shoes-02-model-f-SHOE-CREAM-PEEP.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "shoes-v3-1.0",
      "title": "Cream Block-Heel Peep-Toes",
      "product_image": "exchange/accessories/SHOE-CREAM-PEEP.jpg",
      "purpose": "The demo's suggestion for a lower heel in a neutral colour",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "accessories-03",
      "source": "accessories",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "shoes",
      "sku": "SHOE-GOLD-BROGUE",
      "model": "model-f",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-f.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/shoes-03-model-f-SHOE-GOLD-BROGUE.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "shoes-v3-1.0",
      "title": "Metallic Platform Brogues",
      "product_image": "exchange/accessories/SHOE-GOLD-BROGUE.jpg",
      "purpose": "The flattest pair: a lower heel in a bright colour",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "accessories-04",
      "source": "accessories",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "shoes",
      "sku": "SHOE-NUDE-PUMP",
      "model": "model-f",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-f.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/shoes-04-model-f-SHOE-NUDE-PUMP.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "shoes-v3-1.0",
      "title": "Nude Suede Pumps",
      "product_image": "exchange/accessories/SHOE-NUDE-PUMP.jpg",
      "purpose": "A neutral pair with a heel as high as the boots",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "accessories-bag-probe",
      "source": "accessories",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "bag",
      "sku": "BAG-RED-HOBO",
      "title": "Red Slouch Shoulder Bag",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/bag-probe-model-a-BAG-RED-HOBO.jpg",
      "product_image": "exchange/accessories/BAG-RED-HOBO.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "bag-v2-1.0",
      "purpose": "Bag probe: test whether only the bag changes.",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": "Bag V2 drew the red shoulder bag well, but it made a new picture around it: a gallery background, a green dress in place of the white tee and jeans, and a new pose. Its documentation describes preset styles, chosen at random by default, and a fixed output size. That cannot show a shopper's own bag on them, and each bag would come with a different outfit, so the comparison would not be fair. The other three bags did not run, and Rechoice compares bags by their catalog details only.",
      "outside_change_pct": null,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "looks-01",
      "source": "looks",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "look",
      "sku": "CALM-07+LIP-VELVET-230+NECK-AMETHYST-S55",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/look-01-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4, makeup-vto-1.1, necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Look 1",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The judge path's first suggested top with the lipstick and the necklace the shopper keeps. The first two steps were made by the looks probe on 28 October 2026",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "looks-02",
      "source": "looks",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "look",
      "sku": "CALM-04+LIP-VELVET-230+NECK-AMETHYST-S55",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/look-02-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4, makeup-vto-1.1, necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Look 2",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The judge path's second suggested top, with the same lipstick",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    },
    {
      "id": "looks-03",
      "source": "looks",
      "split": "development",
      "category": "look",
      "sku": "ORIGINAL+LIP-VELVET-230+NECK-AMETHYST-S55",
      "model": "model-a",
      "person_image": "exchange/models/model-a.jpg",
      "result_image": "exchange/evidence/look-03-step3-model-a-NECK-AMETHYST-S55.jpg",
      "recorded_on": "2026-10-28",
      "provider_version": "cloth-v4, makeup-vto-1.1, necklace-vto-1.0",
      "title": "Look 3",
      "product_image": null,
      "purpose": "The top bought, with the same lipstick: what the shopper has now, made the same way",
      "prior_review": null,
      "finding": null,
      "outside_change_pct": 0.0,
      "checks": [
        {
          "kind": "image_fidelity",
          "status": "not_measured",
          "note": "No validated automated product-detail check for this category."
        }
      ],
      "review": null
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "All current outcomes are development cases already inspected or used while building the checks. There are zero held-out outcomes.",
    "Measurements are recomputed from committed public JPEGs, so they can differ from earlier full-resolution private-pilot readings.",
    "Garment colour and relative earring size are narrow checks, not an overall preview-accuracy score. The reference earring is excluded from the size denominator.",
    "Applied-shade readings are uncalibrated. No shade accuracy or visible-requested-change success rate is claimed.",
    "Outside-region pixel change uses fixed approximate boxes, a 256-pixel working image and threshold 40. It is exploratory, not a face-identity, pose or background-preservation verdict; no pass threshold is defined.",
    "The ten existing clothes reviews were written by an AI assistant, were not blind, and are separate from any new rubric ratings. No independent human review is implied.",
    "The rejected bag probe is included. The rejected necklace result and unpublished private pilot outputs are described in the evidence but cannot be remeasured from this public dataset.",
    "These are synthetic demo people and a small catalog, not a shopper study or evidence of reduced returns. There is no combined pass rate.",
    "For a future held-out study, select new cases and freeze this protocol before collecting outputs. Keep development and held-out results separate and report all exclusions."
  ]
}
